Burns on cybersecurity

comment 1
Privacy

Experts warn of ‘shockingly awful’ security against cyber attacks

I don’t agree with everything The National says or does, but I do like giving quotes to them because I can be punchy.

Case in point being today’s article on cybersecurity: in which I gently advise Scotland’s readers to put down their smelling salts and un-clench their pearls about cybersecurity threats from AI or China or what have you, when the Scottish public sector is still staffed by blithering idiots who put untrained, unvetted randos straight onto public data systems.

(And yes, some of you know my priors on this.)

You also have loopholes in the law – very recent loopholes, as it turns out – which allow that to happen without consequence. The example given in the piece is the Scottish NHS, which has always been an innovator in contemptible data handling practices, as practiced by equally contemptible NHS staff. They’re so proud of that, in fact, that they formalised it into Scottish law, as I discussed in the piece.

Having learned all of this the hard way long before they hammered it into statute, as a rule I do not use the Scottish NHS unless I am bleeding from the wrong place at the wrong time (e.g. my bizarre gardening incidents) and even then I don’t trust a single one of them or a believe a single word they say.

Neither should you.

Oh sit down, oh sit down, oh sit down, sit down next to me

Musings

In a week of change and closure and moral arcs bending, I spotted something I’ve never seen before, and that was our Alan all alone.

‘Our Alan’ being Alan Turing, which is to say the statue of him in Manchester. It’s located by his old office, and a minute’s walk from the Crown Court where he was convicted of gross indecency for being gay, a ruling which led to his chemical castration and early death. This is still his neighbourhood, for better and for worse.

Unlike most memorial statues, Alan is not standing on a plinth gazing triumphantly at the skies. He’s sitting on a bench, looking you right in the eye, asking you a question that only you know. That’s the point.

And normally Alan has a crowd around him, reading his story and listening to what he has to say. You also often find someone sitting down with him in silent conversation – and yes, on occasion, that has been me. But there was no one there, at all.

I thought that was a poignant metaphor for the past few years, when the fight for a better society, and better technology uplifting that society, has been all but forgotten. As for the hatred and bigotry that Alan is there to remind you about too, there is work to do. There is so much work to do.

You can start as you should, by sitting down.

Alan Turing's statue in Sackville Gardens, MCR, on an overcast autumn day. There is no one else there.

The threads that bind us

CN x TP

This past weekend, I went to the UK AIDS Quilt on display in Glasgow. Crafted over a decade from the mid-80s to the mid-90s, it is a smaller cousin of its more famous US relative, though no less meaningful for that.

To say that I went to “see” it feels wrong, as does saying I went to “visit” it. The only phrase that feels right is to say that that I bore witness to it.

The idea of the project was simple: each panel had to measure about 3ft by 6ft, or about the size of a typical grave plot. When you stand in front of the panels, that is what you feel you are looking at. It is like a living cemetery, with so many bodies laid out. There are many men; there are also women; there are children; there are babies.

Read More

Shall we play a game?

Policy

There are two things that I love a whole lot. One is speculative fiction. The other is a really good wargaming exercise. In fact, I’d hold that both are essential to any career in policy that isn’t just mealy-mouthed corporate lobbying.

Which is why this cruel but brilliant speculative policy exercise, put forth in this week’s newsletter from Tech Policy Press, made my heart sing and scream in anguish at the same time:

Read More

Back to first principles

Policy

The metric is not the mission

Konstantinos Komaitis has turned some musings which he chose to edit out of his upcoming book into an essay series, which is being serialised over on Techdirt:

The Metric Is Not the Mission is a ten-part examination of how Big Tech moved from building and expanding the open internet to increasingly shaping it around its own metrics, incentives and assumptions. Across the series, the argument follows the evolution of the platform economy—from the optimism of the early internet to the growing tensions around power, prediction, geopolitics, accountability and the future of digital life.

The series will be published in two parts each week over five weeks, with each installment building on the one before it. At the end of the series, the complete essay will be brought together in a single PDF edition, providing the full argument in one place.

It is really, really good, and you should take it in.

KK and I are both 1990s dialup telnet teenagers who remember the starting point of the open commercial internet from its first principles. I don’t say that to remind you how wheezingly old we are damn good we both look for our age; I say that because our shared origin point, as teenagers listening to the modem sing, is the bias we bring to our work in policy, for better or for worse.

I’ve written before about how disorienting it is to sometimes find myself in meetings with colleagues who are younger than some of my coats and jackets, whose origin points for their work in policy is the big tech-era Silicon Valley social media hellscape. What KK and I grew up with is incomprehensible to them, as are the first principles we advocate from.

It’s a small wonder any of us, fighting the same battles on the same side, find common ground at all. I think KK’s series might go some way into building that bridge.

KK gave me the first step up to where I am today, so imploring you, dear readers, to take in the full series is the least I can do in return.

I’m a what now?!

Policy

Over at Techdirt, a post I wrote on this blog several months ago has inspired a post of its own:

Would The Next George Floyd Video Survive Meta’s New Teen Safety Rules?

I’m a very very very longtime reader of Techdirt and even went on the podcast several years ago in that regrettable formal professional capacity I worked in at the time. That of course was a long time ago. So with this new Techdirt post, normally I’d roll my eyes and giggle, but I’m going to go out of my usual character and say that this is a very nice thing, for this reason: Read More

Safe to call out this bullshit

Privacy / UK policy

Dearest readers, I want to call your attention to some outstanding investigative journalism by Martin Calladine.

Part 1: Unsuitable Viewing for a Minister

Part 2: Prophets without profits

He has dug through the accounts of the company behind the snake oil magical nudity detection software which is being mandated for all UK phones –

remember that? The one which prompted Jess Philips to resign from her Ministerial post because Keir Starmer wasn’t battering it straight through into law?

The software being sold by the company which previously cuddled up to that famous defender of young peoples’ virtues, the Nonce Formerly Known as Prince Andrew?

Yes, that company which started its rapacious lobbying journey by placing a scare story across the UK media claiming that precious British children under the age of 10 were using the names of Nando’s hot sauces as their secret texting code for explicit sexual acts?

Yes, them.

Martin has found some cold, hard, ugly, beautiful numbers showing how the whole company is smoke and mirrors.

Albeit smoke and mirrors personally invested in by…Rupert Lowe of the Restore party.

That’s the far right for you. Screaming about government intrusion into privacy and censorship of free expression out of one side of their mouths, whilst investing in it for fun and profit out of the other.

Oh, and they’ve lobbied The Actual Pope too, having randomly discovered Jesus, conveniently, during an industry investment conference deep in the heart of Christofascist America.

As you do.

Martin has receipts on that too. In fact, the harder you dig around this company, the more you find.

Amen to that.

🚨Exclusive🚨
Two ministers filmed a video for a child-protection software firm that lost £17m in three years, made just *£112* in the UK in 2024 and gets 90%+ of its income from overseas subsidiaries that haven’t cooperated with auditors for three years.
1/
theuglygame.wordpress.com/2026/07/15/p…

[image or embed]

— Martin Calladine (@uglygame.bsky.social) 15 July 2026 at 17:11

Going bla bla bla about wtf

UK policy

I had a natter with David Meyer about the past fortnight in UK tech policy drama.

We did this deliberately as a casual chat, as opposed to a techlaw deep dive, so don’t expect anything too heavy. (I had in fact planned to switch off my brain this summer like normal policy wonks do. So much for that…)

The Nerve of this woman

UK policy

Scan your eyeballs, think of the children: how Britain sells surveillance as safety

I wrote for The Nerve about the past fortnight in UK tech policy.

I know a lot of people expected me to have a lot of things to say about what’s happened, but here’s the thing:

aside from that article, there is absolutely nothing to say that I didn’t already say here in this blog, in my fleeting and regrettable professional capacities, or in the media, in (checks notes)
2026, 2025, 2024, 2023, 2022, 2021, 2020, 2019, 2018, 2017, and 2016.

Which is why I took that article right back to where it began, ten years ago next week. Everything always circles right back to where it began. And I do mean everything.